21 January 2015

Private Education vs Public Education

Assalamualaikum...

When Imani reached the age of 2 years old, we knew that we have to start our research on schools and line of education that we wish to embed in our family. We know it’s hard but we never expected it to be the hardest plus most difficult research we ever took as a parent. 

Play school was easy. We know exactly what we want to instill in our kids. No exams. No ranking. PLAY only. Do not fall to the famous name easily. Advertisement can sometimes quite misleading. I suggest, prepare a list of available school within your area, take a day off and interview the owner. What we did was, surveyed the school facilities and interviewed the school’s operator (aimed for the principal please). In a day, we went to 4 schools and settled down with one chosen by Imani herself. Alhamdulillah, it was a great experience so far.

When Imani reached the age of 6 years old, we already have our shortlisted schools. And being a choosy mother, my selection was not within my area only, I had an alternative selection should the 1st option was not made available to us. And that alternative included a relocation of our permanent address.

Ok. So what is the best? A public school or a private school?

Private School

If you choose a private schools, you should understand what kind of future you plan for your kids. It won’t be a red carpet treatment i.e. in term of monetary, you will not be given any subsidy in school fees, books etc. Same goes to a boarding school, once you enrolled your kid to a private education, unless they took their UPSR, they are not eligible to attend any boarding school for primary education.

Same goes to, pursuing their education abroad, a normal scholarship will not be easy no matter how many A1s they manage to achieve in their exam.  Government or government linked organization will normally offer their scholarship to the high flyers student graduating from famous public boarding school for a like of Sekolah Tun Fatimah , Malay College Kuala Kangsar or MRSM.

As parents, if you opt for a private school, you have to establish a strong financial sustainability. You have to have fund readily available to pay for the school fees (which normally more expensive as the teachers are not locally bred), the programmes and the books.
In contrast, a private school offers an independent, non-exam-oriented environment. A holistic upbringing involving independent thinking, critical analysis and soft skills. By sending your kid to a private school, you are basically teaching them to think out of the box. You are not producing a job seeker individual, instead you are producing a real life survivor.

Public School

As most of public school is funded by government, there is no risk of getting your kids a proper education should there is any mishap in between i.e. loss of employment, economic downturn resulting in lower currency value etc.  You could spend you extra money for additional soft skill classes outside the classroom.

If your kids excel, options are open for them. They can choose for a science school, or religious school or combination of both. And the teachers nowadays are well trained, both in theories and analytic skill. As the programs are normally free, your kid will have vast opportunity to enter any competition to their like and expertise.

The bad is, most public school is an exam oriented place. The kids will have long list of subjects to attend to. The kids will be ranked and grouped based on their exam’s result. Priority and focus will also be given to the higher performance classes to represent school in any program, to experience new modules to the least of being the school prefect. This, ultimately resulting in parents sending their kid for tuition which will normally cost them a hole in their pocket.

And please do not think of holistic upbringing. Few good school does teach and exposure their student for analytic skill and survivor attitude, but most are not. It’s not anyone mistake, it’s the culture. If the kids not performing well in exam, they are nobody, resulting in their 110%’s effort wasted on books. 

So parents, choose and decide wisely. 

No comments:

Post a Comment

About Me

A wife, a mother of three and still surviving the corporate jungle. Wish I could give back to people, and put a mark or two in their life. Planning,negotiation and interpersonal skills are my expertise. Let's get connected.